I have had to accept the inevitable: Penny is going to dry up this time. We can breed her again as soon as she's physically ready and in estrus, but for now, I have to let it go. It's disappointing, but I know it's for the best.
Penny was making some swift improvements, but then a confluence of events occurred over which we had little to no control. First, she got a significant skin wound just above her left knee, leaving me unable to use the goat hobbles as she was used to. Instead, I had to use the new, strong, perfect goat hobbles when they finally arrived around her ankles. She did not like this. Did I mention goats are extreme creatures of habit? Just when I got her used to the hobbles above her knees, we had to switch down to her ankles. She had been in the very first stages of standing still for me to milk. We were going from two hours of working together each time to 45 minutes. We went straight back to two hours
plus and she wasn't even empty when I finally gave up.
While her routine was changing for the umpteenth time in less than two weeks, it started raining. And raining. And raining. And her barn floor went from fairly dry straw to sloppy, mucky, quicksand-like mud puddles in about three days time. Did I mention goats do not like water, especially on their feet?
We covered the barn with a tarp for extra protection. Still the rain came down around it, seeping in under the walls. We let her sleep on her milkstand. We put an army cot in for her. Meanwhile, both the front and back exit became so wet and mucky they tried to pull my boots off every time I went out there. She started refusing to come out, even to browse for food.
It was too wet to get the fence in good shape, so we bought concrete blocks for her floor. Still the rain came down, and the concrete blocks are waiting in the back of our truck for a day sunny enough (tomorrow I hope!) to get a truckload of sand to put under the blocks and create a nice dry barn floor for her.
Day one of the downhill slope, I got her up on the milkstand and began very patiently. I would reach for her udders and she would kick up with her new hobble, then slip on the milk stand from all the wet, then freak herself out even more. I would touch her udder again, she would kick. Touch udder. Kick. Slip. Freak out. Touch udder. Kick. I would hold her leg, she would fight as if it were for her life. I would take a break, take a breather. Touch udder. Kick. Slip. Freak out. Kick. Slip. On and on. I became more matter-of-fact with her, then enraged, then I cried. Then she let me empty her, which took a total of 20 minutes on each side. Two and a half hours later I was bringing less than a quart of milk into the house. Most of it had to thrown out because it was too dirty from all the mud slung around.
That night I went to
(shudder) WalMart, evil of evil that it is, to buy her a non-slip mat for her milkstand. Desperate times call for desperate measures.
Day two of the downhill slope, I went out in the morning. The milkstand was too wet to install the mat, but I couldn't get it out of the barn with my pregnancy, so I planned to install it later that afternoon when Jeff could drag out the milkstand so I could clean it. It was supposed to be sunny and dry that day. It wasn't. It got soppier and wetter and muckier and yuckier.
And Penny had learned that if she kicked enough with her hobbles near her ankles, she could get quite some vertical action. Enough to get me to quit messing with her. At least, that's how I read it that day. In reality, she could have been even more upset about the lack of browse, the wet, the slippery milkstand, and my wacked-out emotions the day before. I was far from my Zen place already when I first walked in the door. I think she smelled it a mile away.
For two hours I tried to empty her. I got one side halfway emptied and the other side barely touched. I felt violent toward the poor goat. I hate feeling violent toward anything, except maybe my computer on occasion (shhh...don't tell it). Finally, after telling her over and over how she was not going to win this, she might as well give up, well...I gave up and she did win.
Here's a little thing that I struggle with in my personality - I do not like to fail. It doesn't matter if other people consider it a failure, or if it's even all that important to me. I refuse to fail. This can create a lot of
pressure in situations like these. I felt like I was on a deadline to get it straight before she dried up. I felt like I wanted to succeed at it very badly, especially for Mazzy's dairy-free diet sake. Yet, our success wasn't entirely dependent on me. It was also dependent on Penny, and on the normal time constraints that come with having a family, and on the weather. It's hard to refuse to fail at something when there are so many factors out of your control.
Fast forward to later on the second Very Hard Day. I started getting really crampy in my lower belly. On the first Very Hard Day, I kept trying to pull Penny closer while she kept trying to hover near the wall where I couldn't reach her. One time that I pulled her toward me, I also pulled something in my belly and I felt it as soon as it happened. When I started cramping the next day and it didn't quit, I knew what had to happen. I had to let this go for right now.
Jeff, in a last-ditch attempt to save her milk, tried modifying the milk stand with something permanent that would keep her legs in place. She squatted and refused to let anyone near her udders. He gave up, and we haven't looked back. It's the right decision. Does it count as failure when it's a conscious choice, I wonder?
There were four major factors that contributed to my choice.
Penny was rapidly developing a negative connotation with her milkstand and with being milked. She would continually shake and shiver and barely breathe while on the milkstand. She stopped having the grain that was right in front of her and would just stand shaking in obvious fear. She comes from great milking bloodlines. I'd prefer to not lose the ability to milk her entirely by pushing it right now.
I was over-exerting myself for this stage of pregnancy, and although having more healthy food choices for Mazzy is extremely important to me, not threatening the unborn baby is more important. I'm not a stranger to pregnancy loss.
The stress in our household since we've been trying so hard to milk such a reluctant milker has been
insane. I would welcome the opportunity to learn how to care for her, house her, and bond with her without having the milking in the equation right now.
The girls and I still do have a life, and everything else was falling by the wayside to make room for the milking and the ensuing exhaustion. 20 minutes once, even twice a day, no problem. Two
hours once or twice a day? I'm sorry, but I can't keep that up.
So what's the plan now? You know I have one!
Well, my plan is to really focus my energy on learning how to care for her and create a strong bond with her before we try again. I've been consulting my internal dog training experience as well as any goat behavior books I can find to develop a training plan for her to help us milk later. I plan to feed her grain twice a day in her milkstand with her head in the head lock while I first pet her and make her comfortable, then move on to brushing and eventually working with her udders again, even when she's not in milk.
We'll let the hobbles go until her wound is completely healed, but they will come back as part of her eating routine. She should be quite comfortable being handled by the time she can be bred again.
We're also looking for a companion goat for her. A local breeder was recommended to us by a woman in our homeschool co-op. As soon as I can get in touch with the breeder, I'd like to see what she suggests. We are thinking either a young dairy doeling or an older doe that is already in milk but is a second or third freshener. We could try to milk her before we left the breeder's farm. An easy milker would be a welcome addition to our little homestead at any time.
And now, I'm looking at Penny as if we'd never tried to milk her. Let bygones be bygones. I love her too much to hold onto anger over this. As far as I'm concerned, we got a sweet, friendly goat from great milking bloodlines, and as soon as we can breed her, we can give milking a fresh try.